Thanks to everyone who responded to my idea. I now feel free to get the ball rolling with a game, so to speak.

In his book on the 1995 San Francisco international, Jim Eade offhandedly remarked how Jonathan Tisdall "missed one-move wins in both the second and third rounds". Well, this Analysis Club game was Tisdall's second round matchup with Maurice Ashley. Since Eade didn't provide the winning move, as though the win was so easy to find anyone would see it, I admit to being baffled.

Jonathan D Tisdall vs Maurice Ashley (1995)

Please allow a few days before replying to give everyone a chance to sink their teeth into the game.